reasons to legalize weed

8 Reasons Why Marijuana Should Be Legalized

Would the USA be a better place with legal pot?

  • Share
  • Flipboard
  • Email

Justin Sullivan / Getty Images

  • Ph.D., Religion and Society, Edith Cowan University
  • M.A., Humanities, California State University – Dominguez Hills
  • B.A., Liberal Arts, Excelsior College

Several states have legalized marijuana in recent years, either for medicinal use, recreational use or both. But possession, sale or use of the drug still is considered a crime at the federal level and most states.

Regardless of one’s position on the explanations for marijuana prohibition, there are two sides to the debate. These are the arguments in favor of legalization.

Shaky Legal Ground

There are always reasons why laws exist. While some advocates for the status quo claim that marijuana laws prevent people from harming themselves, the most common rationale is that they prevent people from harming themselves and from causing harm to the larger culture.

But laws against self-harm always stand on shaky ground—predicated, as they are, on the idea that the government knows what’s good for you better than you do, and no good ever comes from making governments the guardians of culture.

Racially Discriminatory

The burden of proof for marijuana prohibition advocates would be high enough if marijuana laws were enforced in a racially neutral manner, but—this should come as no surprise to anyone familiar with our country’s long history of racial profiling—they are most definitely not.

According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Black and white people use marijuana at roughly the same rates.   And yet, Black people are nearly four times more likely to be arrested for a drug-related crime.  

Enforcement is Prohibitively Expensive

In 2005, Milton Friedman and a group of over 500 other economists advocated for marijuana legalization on the basis that prohibition directly costs more than $7.7 billion per year.

Enforcement is Unnecessarily Cruel

You don’t have to look very hard to find examples of lives needlessly destroyed by marijuana prohibition laws. The government arrests about 700,000 Americans—more than the population of Wyoming—for marijuana possession every year. These new “convicts” are driven from their jobs and families and pushed into a prison system that turns first-time offenders into hardened criminals.

Impedes Criminal Justice Goals

Just as alcohol prohibition essentially created the American Mafia, marijuana prohibition has created an underground economy where crimes unrelated to marijuana, but connected to people who sell and use it, go unreported. End result: Real crimes become harder to solve.

Cannot Be Consistently Enforced

Every year, an estimated 2.4 million people use marijuana for the first time. Most will never be arrested for it. A small percentage, usually low-income people of color, arbitrarily will.

If the objective of marijuana prohibition laws is to actually prevent marijuana use rather than driving it underground, then the policy is, despite its astronomical cost, an utter failure from a pure law enforcement point of view.

Taxing It Can Be Profitable

A 2010 Fraser Institute study found that legalizing and taxing marijuana could produce considerable revenue for British Columbia. Economist Stephen T. Easton estimated the annual amount at $2 billion.

Alcohol and Tobacco Are Far More Harmful

The case for tobacco prohibition is actually much stronger than the case for marijuana prohibition since tobacco has provably harmful effects and no benefits.

Alcohol prohibition has, of course, already been tried. And, judging by the history of the war on drugs, legislators have apparently learned nothing from this failed experiment.

Further, it is impossible to overdose on marijuana since a pot smoker would have to consume 20,000 to 40,000 times the amount of THC in a single joint to produce a lethal dose.

Marijuana is also far less addictive than other drugs. According to CNN medical correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta, the numbers for adult dependence are:

  • marijuana: 9-10 percent
  • cocaine: 20 percent:
  • heroin: 25 percent
  • tobacco: 30 percent

8 economic and social arguments why marijuana should be legalized. Governments could save money (prisons) and generate new incomes (taxes) with legal pot.

5 Economic Reasons to Legalize Marijuana

Legal cannabis could lead to job creation, added tax revenue, and a host of other benefits.

Within the U.S., the marijuana industry has come an incredibly long way in just over two decades. According to a Gallup Poll from 1995, the year before California became the first state to legalize medical cannabis for compassionate-use patients, just 25% of respondents favored legalizing pot. Mind you, this was also during a time when the Drug Abuse Resistance Education (DARE) program was still a mainstay in public schools.

However, just 23 years later, there are now 29 states that have broadly sweeping medical marijuana laws, and nine states that have OK’d adult-use cannabis. Gallup’s October 2017 survey also found that an all-time-high 64% of respondents favor legalizing marijuana. In fact, five national polls conducted over the trailing year have all shown overwhelming support for legalizing weed (with a range of 59% to 64% for approval).

Image source: Getty Images.

Why isn’t cannabis legal in the U.S.?

So, if the public is in favor of legalizing pot, why isn’t marijuana legal at the federal level?

To begin with, Republicans aren’t exactly angling for reform. Though there are few categories of people who are opposed, or mixed, in their view of cannabis, Republicans and senior citizens tend to be the most opposed to the expansion of weed. Considering that the GOP is firmly in control of Congress at the moment, there’s virtually no incentive for them to take up reform — especially with a busy docket.

Along those same lines, cannabis isn’t a political game-changer — at least not yet. A survey conducted by Quinnipiac University in April found that 82% of respondents could still vote for a candidate even if that candidate didn’t share their view on legalizing cannabis. In other words, politicians don’t yet have to worry about being voted out of office for having a negative view on cannabis.

There’s also a steady stream of concerns regarding legalization, such as what might happen with adolescent access if there were a sudden proliferation of legal weed, or how driving-under-the-influence laws could be impacted. Though there are numerous marijuana breathalyzer prototypes in development, there isn’t that line-in-the-sand regulation for driving under the influence with marijuana as there is with alcohol, which poses a challenge.

All of these factors pretty aptly summarize why marijuana remains a Schedule I drug, and therefore wholly illegal.

Image source: Getty Images.

Five economic reasons to consider legalizing weed

But there are a laundry list of economic reasons why legalization might make sense. If we were to look at marijuana from a purely dollar-based standpoint, here are five compelling reasons why legalizing cannabis is attractive.

1. It would raise a substantial amount of revenue for federal and/or state governments

For starters, legalizing marijuana could put a lot of money into the pockets of individual states and the federal government. Cannabis data analytics firm New Frontier Data released a report in 2017 estimating that the immediate legalization of marijuana at the federal level would lead to $131.8 billion in aggregate federal tax revenue being collected between 2017 and 2025. New Frontier Data came up with this figure based on a 15% retail sales tax, payroll tax deductions, and business tax revenue.

It’s worth noting that the corporate tax rate used in these calculations was 35%, which was the peak business tax rate before the tax cuts in December 2017. With a new (and reduced) peak business tax rate of 21%, this tax-revenue estimate has probably fallen a bit. Nonetheless, the point is that the federal government could go from collecting virtually no revenue annually from cannabis (it does currently tax corporate income for marijuana-based businesses), to generating perhaps $10 billion-plus annually.

Image source: Getty Images.

2. Legalizing cannabis would create a lot of jobs

Legalizing marijuana would also be a major boon to the jobs market. Understandably, it’s not as if that’s hurting at the moment, with the latest jobs report showing an 18-year-low unemployment rate of just 3.8%. However, New Frontier also estimates that the immediate legalization of cannabis, and its steady growth through 2025, could lead to the cumulative creation of 1.1 million jobs.

Where would these job opportunities come from? We’d obviously see immediate demand from jobs that put workers in direct contact with the cannabis plant: farmers, processors, distributors, and retailers. Basically any business directly involved with the cannabis supply chain.

Yet, we’d also see a considerable uptick in ancillary pot businesses. Think about consulting firms, software developers that cater to the cannabis industry, financing and lending services, and construction firms tasked with building retail outlets and greenhouses. The list could go on, but the main point here is that it would immediately create a lot of new direct and indirect jobs.

Image source: Getty Images.

3. Investors could benefit from the long-term growth of the legal pot industry

Another reason to consider legalizing marijuana in the U.S. is that it could help put investors on track to retire comfortably. To be clear, marijuana isn’t the only fast-growing industry at the moment, and I’m certain it’ll encounter its own set of growth hiccups, as any other industry does over time. The point is that as long as cannabis remains illegal at the federal level, investors have little ability to take advantage of its enormous growth potential, unless of course they’re willing to cross their fingers and buy a penny stock on an over-the-counter exchange.

If cannabis were legal, marijuana stocks would be free to list on reputable U.S. exchanges, which would improve their liquidity and beef up reporting standards. More important, it would give investors the opportunity to take advantage of what could be double-digit growth rates for many years to come.

Image source: Getty Images.

4. Billions of dollars saved in law-enforcement costs

Legalizing marijuana wouldn’t be just about the amount of dollars working their way into the system. It would also entail saving some of the dollars that might otherwise be flowing out of the system. In 2013, a report from the American Civil Liberties Union found that federal marijuana enforcement costs approximately $3.6 billion a year. If cannabis were made legal, these costs would drop dramatically.

Additionally, removing marijuana from the controlled-substances list would reduce the number of court cases that go to trial. Fewer court cases mean fewer incarcerations, and therefore a lot of saved money.

Image source: Getty Images.

5. A long-term reduction in cannabis prices

Last, but not least, legalizing marijuana in the U.S. would likely lead to a commoditization of dried cannabis over the long run, and therefore lower weed prices.

While lower cannabis prices wouldn’t exactly be good news for marijuana stocks or the federal government, which is collecting tax revenue based on total sales, it could be stellar news for medical patients. Those folks who are benefiting from access to marijuana, cannabidiol oil, and other cannabis-based products would likely find that their medicines are considerably more affordable if pot is legal.

Are these economic reasons enough to convince lawmakers to consider legalizing marijuana in the United States? Only time will give us that answer.

Legal cannabis could lead to job creation, added tax revenue, and a host of other benefits.